[Sig makers ONLY rate the sig]

ok then, i guess i'll start.

i haven't made any in about a month or so but these are considered my best works.

 

I can see what you mean by "just now" (looks kind of rushed =P). I do like how the Red and Aqua lines glow on the Render (is that right? I've always just called it the image) and the text placement and colour of "VENGEANCE" is swell, unfortunately "leaves for no happy endings" doesn't stand out as well (I can see you're trying to do a duo colour theme (I think) neato, but unfortunate for that text >.<) and did you trace around the image in the background with a pencil on some places? I kind of like it, it looks like a unique trademark effect one would do to say it's theirs instead of putting in their name ^^
Out of a 10 I would give it something around a 9. Maybe an 8 if I were an absolute hard ass but I'm not ^^
(Hope that's not too much)

Here's my latest, I know I'm missing something but I don't know what it is. Or maybe there is too much of something =\

 

cool concept, bit to dark and plain though. add some brighter colours and greater depth and it would be a greater improvement. - 6.5/10

 

9.5/10- I really like the use of brushes and blurs. One thing, I don't like is the text. It looks a bit creepy, next to the beautiful design. Sorry, I can't describe it better than that.

 

I forgot to resize them, so us some imagination to image a couple of them smaller

I made this one day for legendseeker


another one


I made this out of game sprites I have, this one is a little cheesy. some giant lizards go for some nice toads


here's another one that's a little cheesy. the mario brothers meet the godzilla brothers


smaus aran one, I expect some bad reviews on some, but hopefully a couple of good reviews

 

Disclaimer: Mkay. Since this thread is for sig makers, I'll be doing my "professional critique", so if I come off as mean or anything, I'm not being mean. I'm just commenting on your work as a sig maker who's not bad and has a little bit of experience. I'm just saying this as one of my past forums got a little iffy when I did this and didn't mention I was critiquing like this. =]
----------
So I'll number these from one to five. XD
1. It's really just two inverted images on a black background with some plain text. =\ If you rendered the images, good job, though. Also, the text isn't uniformly aligned. I'd recommend using some brushes in the background, and maybe applying some more interesting filters. ^^; 4/10
2. This is just stock with text. D= I can't really see anything else that has been done to it, and it hasn't been saved at high enough quality to prevent artifacts appearing around the text. 3/10. Sorry!
3 & 4. Creative sigs! The top one is a bit large for my liking, but the concept is till good. 7/10 for both.
5. Same as number one. ^^;

Again, sorry if I come off as harsh. I found that not "beating about the bush" when I was reviewed helped me immensely. If you saw some of my original stuff, you'd definitely be able to see. =P
----------
I also see Hope didn't get a rating! Nice composition, and good stock quality. Nice brush use and text placement. Only problem is that I think that the white regions would be better as transparent areas. 8.5/10

 

I don't know what to say really, it's all so perfect.
It breaks the 10 if anything ^^
Text is out of the way and is nice and clear.
Nice colour scheme for the concept of it.
But I do have one thing I can say that's not positive.
Empty Space =\
But that's just me, I prefer to have it all filled and try fill up the spaces.
I'm still giving it a 10 because the positive points of it makes up for the empty space =]

___________________________________________
Lately I've been toying around with small images, and these are my latest ones.

 

Rawr: thanks for your comments.

doc rocco: well pracite makes perfect, so thanks for your comments.

I remember those sigs he made. I got them saved on my computer
also, I made this one recently

 

I made it on that Luna Pic website Hope showed us

 

Please stay on topic

It's a good animation but the writing could be a lot better.
Overal: 8/10

 

please, unless you're a mod, don't tell us to stay on topic
but I like the sig you have at the bottom. you make that? if so, I give it a 9/10

 

Hey, I know it's not my job to tell you to keep on topic but still if you wanted to talk PM each other
and yes I did make it

To Honor guard's sig:
I like the animation loads XD! 9/10

 

yes, people on fire is pretty cool. 8.5/10 for yours. this one I made just recently. it's still pretty plain, I'm not really good with backrounds.

 

Pretty cool, better than mine. 9/10

 

yours is still awesome Star. LLAMAS!!!

this is another one I made off a saying I heard

 

10/10 for big freakin sword!