[Sig makers ONLY rate the sig]

Firstly, Higher qual images are needed on all.

ok, 1st one. - 2 focal points is a difficult thing to pull off, generally they need to be close and thats where you failed mainly on that one. Colours are fine, bring the renders to the center, sharpen them up and get rid of the logo's. Get creative with your own style of typography. - 3/10

2nd One. - not much to say, just follow some tutorials and pick up tricks really. You got the idea of flow down, add some brushes, smudges and c4d's in. You really want to follow a few tutorials to pick up some tricks before you make many more (don't want to fall into any bad habbits). - 3/10

3rd one. - biggest problem here is the empty space. Personally I feel having a stock like that is difficult with text. Use the sharpen and blur tools on the background and create better depth. Play with the colours and rearrange the stock and text until it looks better (sorry cant give suggestions where, find it difficult myself. The render is far too long) - 3/10

 

In prep for SOTW =P

I probably have little chance if the big guns are competing (you know who you are), so I'd like to improve (in general, not for SOTW) with some criticism placed on me and perhaps a few notes to help out as well if you can (unlike the first time I posted here)
(as a side note, I need photoshop >.<)


As for Pulse, I can't say much apart from saying how great it is. I like how the render kind of pops out from the image itself.
You've used the space well filling gaps and the colour scheme is nice. That blue scribble behind the text and main image is unique, but I'm not seeing it making the sig better. It's actually kind of distracting me from the render. You could have done a bit more with the purple layer behind your render. It's done well in front of the character but behind him it looks almost as if you stopped trying.
8/10 from me.

 

I am on the same boat as rawr. I am planning to enter the SOTW with this signature, cause Reisen ask me. I am a noob when it comes to graphics, and I just made this. Please go all out on how I can improve my work.

Gracis

 

well I think is pretty.10/10

unlike my sigs,always coming so ugly....I mean look at them,I suck at making sigs..

 

no its good, really

a 9/10

just... less bright

 

well, i think it's nice =] a little bigger would be appreciated.

My third ever real sig:



yes it was a tribute

oh and this one:

 

They're interesting, but they lack a wow factor that I've seen from you before. The tribute one I like more than the second, but there's too much going on.

The second one is nice, but a little bland. I prefer to see color and more movement. Now the text is a bit blurred. I can read it, but it took some straining of the eyes.

Overall I like what you've done, but one has too much, the other too little. Take a bit from the two, and put them together.

 

yesh, i was exited for some sort of Riot =p

 

first and foremost, way to bright. too much white.
the renders are also blurry which is almost never a good thing.
the text doesn't seem to fit really.

overall i give it a 6/10 cause there's obvious effort just the final product doesn't look like it was the desired outcome.



please rate.

 

8/10
donnow, i feel like something is missing. Pretty good, though

 

a lot of random text and simple copy and pasting. 5/10

 

some one please rate mine's.

 

yes it did,thank you so much.

 

Hm, to all the Signature Makers out there... XD

What think you, about this first ever signature I've made hm? I made it using only Iris, an iPhone application, and Picnik, as well as one image from Persona 3 Portable that I found using Google

 

Heres what I have I usually do logos or other stuff so sigs are new but here!
[

 

Ya about the text I usually do logos so text is bigger but that makes since for sigs. I tried to fix his hair. It was a poor stock so it cut off his hair and i tried to snoothy it out but ya fail. I did add some brush things suvh as the lights i had but i agree i dont know i just couldnt think of much more to add. Thanks for the feedback though Toph I'll try to make a new sig soon! (Oh and btw I use Jasc Paintshop Pro 9)