Move, Kinect, or Wii?

I have MANY problems with MANY points of your argument. Allow me to demonstrate.

The Wii does this too. It's done this since it came out, and with the Wii Motion Plus, it got even more accurate.

Once again, the Wii does this too. Maybe not for every game, but for the Swordplay event of Wii Sports Resort, AND for the new Zelda game. Which brings me to my next point...

The Move is a BLATANT Wii ripoff, no matter how you look at it. From the controller to the concept itself.

Refer to the third panel of this comic for further insight into my opinion of the "Sony Move."

 

Can we all just say that the wii is getting old, the move is a rip-off, and the Kinect is really bad at what it does?

Just putting things into perspective, is all.

 

I was gonna say that. Although admittedly I don't know how effective the Wii Motion Plus is since I don't have one. Or a game that uses it....

Of course we can say that. But personally, I thought that the Kinect was a pretty inventive idea. And if it could work better than you guys say it does (Again, haven't used it), then I think it would be interesting to play a Dragon Ball Z game. Only difficult part would be the flying.

 

I personally have opinion on matters. Though I've not played the move nor kinect personally I got friends who have and I've done personal research.

With Kinect you face problems with the fact that it tends to be buggy. I'm not sure if it's just not picking up or what but yeah. That's from internet searches then friends who got it say it works great in the beginning but it gets old sort of quickly. Great concept though to finally get people moving.

The Wii is what I have played before and use. The problem with the wii is it's not 'as' interactive. Granted I don't have the motion plus, but still. There's not enough games that uses the function of the wii motion. Most of the games that I have I can sit on a couch and play them with movement of only just my arms. Not fully body movement(until you get the board for like yoga and stuff but the board just annoys me a whole lot). Other games I don't have to move anything. However we do have the wii to thank for kinect and move because it did show "hey look we can make games much more interactive now." The wii just didn't go as far in the beginning to show us 'how much' it can become interactive.

Now for the move I have heard different stuff about it. First off though, there's not too many games that truly 'use' Move, and the games I've seen using move you don't need your whole body once again. But a few say it's fun to do and apparently there's a dance game with the move that is really awesome. Here's though where the move advances more than the wii(but not to kinect because I know it does this already), but move I believe if I'm thinking of the right thing has a mic on it so different singing sort of games you can sing to it instead of just be singing to the air with no point. This appeals to me more because of my high interests in music(but once again this also happens with Rock Band, it's just not 'as' expensive).


So basically I got mixed views. The only one I have used it the wii and like requeim stated, the wii has just gotten old and I also feel that it more so appeals to just little kids more.

 

Move=Joy
Wii=Crappy waggle fest.

Comparisons: In sports challenge, there is a sword fighting game, were (IK it is crazy but) YOU DON"T HAVE TO WAGGLE!
In Wii Sports Resort, in the sword fighting game, you can waggle! It totaly defeats the perpouse of Wii Motion Plus! Wii motion plus did nothing, it didn't change how you played the game. You could still just move your ris back and forth and win!
In the PSMove if you wagle, u lose. Waggling doesn't work. It's more of good clean REAL movements.
I thought the wii was going to be like that, it wasn't. Then when the PSMove came out and I played it, all I could think about, is how cool playing a KH game on this would be epic.

 

my best friend just bought his Kinect and I plan to play it when I go home for Thanksgiving break so I can't comment on its gameplay at the moment, neither with the Move, but I can comment on the Wii. I've had a Wii system since it came out and I thought I had the most advanced game system out there, you know a game that actually gets you up and moving instead of sitting down on a couch for hours on end. However, now that I see the Kinect that has no controllers at all, I'm thinking the Wii isn't so advanced anymore. I personally enjoy the gameplay of Wii, especially Wii sports but one thing I don't like, and actually this is a major dislike for me, is that when you have to connect your Wii remote to your Nunchuck, you're limited by how far you can spread your arms apart. Now I have really long arms, so for me this is annoying cuz the cord connecting the two is too short for me, and playing Wii Boxing is just not that fun if I can't fully extend my punches. So the Kinect, with "no strings to hold me down" (lol) appeals to me more than the Wii.

 

You do realize that they make wireless nunchucks? Trust me, it makes things MUCH easier.

 

Ok Wii = Crap
Move= Much better but still not my kind of thing.
Kinect= Cool but, i heared some bad things about it, and I don't have a Xbox

@ LDC

The thing is with you thinking the Wii was the most advanced system, is that in all aspects, its the worst.
Worst Graphics is a big one for me.
And for a lot of people, the whole getting up and active in the game doesn't work for them. Im in that group of people.
I like to be able to wake up early on a saterday morning and curl up under a blanket on my couch and sit there motionless(exept for your fingers.)
Lots of people didn't like the whole standing up part of gaming.

 

Hm. I haven't actually heard or seen the other two... Until now, that is... So, my vote goes to the Wii :\ I suppose the three would probably be more or less the same...?

 

*gasp* they make wireless nunchucks!!!! well I know what I'm getting for christmas anyways I don't think that Wii is the most advanced game system as of right now, but when it first came out a few years ago, I did think it was advanced at that time, obviously with the awesome advances in technology since then the Wii is increasingly becoming obsolete.

 

This I agree with, also with the WII the only good game I have seen is SSBB, yet I still do not use the wii remote for, I use the gamecube control for it so it kinda defeats the purpose.

As for Kinect, my friend got one recently, I am hoping to try it this weekend, as for the Move, It will have to wait but from what I have heard it seems pretty good.